Back to the gallery

American Action Forum Inc · DC

Who Do You Trust, Your Pollster or Your Prediction Market?

From Douglas Holtz-Eakin · Nov 2, 2026 · Social science · $2 million to $10 million

Preview text: Daily Dish: November 2nd Edition

Sign in to read the whole email

We’ll email you a link. No password. Once you’re in, every email in the gallery is open to you.

By providing your email you are agreeing to receive future communications from Nonprofit Assessment and Upspire Studio.

In one line

This email discusses the reliability of prediction markets versus polls for forecasting election outcomes.

Kind
Newsletter or update
Approach
Story and numbers
Sent with
Mailchimp
Sent
Monday, 6 a.m. Eastern time

Compared with newsletters and updates from social science organizations with budgets of $2 million to $10 million: 5 organizations, 65 emails over the last year. Each organization counts once.

Where it sits among its peers

Middle half of peersPeers’ medianThis email

  • Buttons

    0 med 2.8

    0most 0–6.67.7
  • Words

    548 med 591

    354most 498–7261274
  • Reading ease

    29 med 29

    15plain English 60–7038
  • “You” for every “we”

    3.5 med 0.7

    0.6most 0.6–1.33.5

    Higher than most peers

  • Different asks in one email

    0 med 0.5

    0most 0–0.50.7

    Fewer than most peers

  • Subject length (characters)

    58 med 49

    30cut off on a phone near 4174

    More than most peers

  • Images

    6 med 11

    6most 8–1218

    Fewer than most peers

  • Images with alt text

    67% med 42%

    0%100%

    Higher than most peers

  • Links

    18 med 21

    14most 21–4757

    Fewer than most peers

  • Size

    63 KB med 87 KB

    54 KBGmail clips at 102 KB105 KB

    Lower than most peers

  • Spam signals

    1 med 0.3

    0most 0.2–0.31

    More than most peers

What it does, against peers

Each figure is the share of peers that do it.

Does it, unlike most peers

  • Signed by a person 1 of 5
  • Subject is a question 1 of 5
  • Links to a donation page 2 of 5

Skips it, unlike most peers

  • Has a button 3 of 5

Skips it, like most peers

  • Invites people to an event 2 of 5
  • DMARC policy set to reject 2 of 5
  • Postal address in the footer 2 of 5
  • Sent on a weekend 2 of 5
  • Leads with a story 1 of 5
  • Reports results as numbers 1 of 5
  • Declares its language 1 of 5
  • Says why you got it 1 of 5
18 more
  • Asks people to volunteer 0 of 5
  • Asks people to take action 0 of 5
  • Mentions planned giving 0 of 5
  • Broken personalization 0 of 5
  • Emoji in the subject 0 of 5
  • Preview spent on “View in browser” 0 of 5
  • Subject starts with “Re:” or “Fwd:” 0 of 5
  • Urgent wording in the subject 0 of 5
  • Reader’s name in the subject 0 of 5
  • Adjusts for dark mode 0 of 5
  • Almost all image 0 of 5
  • Has links without https 0 of 5
  • Long enough that Gmail cuts it off 0 of 5
  • From a person’s name 0 of 5
  • From a person at the organization 0 of 5
  • Sent from a no-reply address 0 of 5
  • Logo shown in the inbox (BIMI) 0 of 5
  • Links carry campaign tags 0 of 5
Does it, like most peers · 14 practices
  • Sent in the morning 3 of 5
  • Subject cut off on a phone 4 of 5
  • Fits a phone screen 4 of 5
  • Unsubscribe link in the email 4 of 5
  • Has preview text 5 of 5
  • Designed (HTML) rather than plain text 5 of 5
  • Includes a plain-text version 5 of 5
  • From the organization’s name 5 of 5
  • Replies reach a real inbox 5 of 5
  • Signed with their own domain 5 of 5
  • One-click unsubscribe 5 of 5
  • Unsubscribe header 5 of 5
  • Links are click-tracked 5 of 5
  • Has an open-tracking pixel 5 of 5

1 spam signal

  • Phrases filters watch for

Things filters are known to hold against an email. Not a prediction.