Back to the gallery

Island Institute · ME

Refining the Art of Delivering Good News

From Kim Hamilton, Island Institute · Nov 10, 2026 · Education · Over $10 million

Preview text: A trusted voice on coastal issues

Sign in to read the whole email

We’ll email you a link. No password. Once you’re in, every email in the gallery is open to you.

By providing your email you are agreeing to receive future communications from Nonprofit Assessment and Upspire Studio.

In one line

This newsletter discusses the decline of local news and its impact on communities.

Kind
Newsletter or update
Main ask
CONTINUE READING
Approach
Leads with a story
Buttons
“CONTINUE READING”, “SUPPORT TRUSTED, LOCAL JOURNALISM”, “DONATE TODAY”
Sent with
Salesforce Account Engagement
Sent
Tuesday, 6 a.m. Eastern time

Compared with newsletters and updates from education organizations with budgets of over $10 million: 13 organizations, 24 emails over the last year. Each organization counts once.

Where it sits among its peers

Middle half of peersPeers’ medianThis email

  • Buttons

    3 med 1

    0most 1–613
  • Words

    252 med 735

    215most 357–8091367

    Fewer than most peers

  • Reading ease

    41 med 38

    19plain English 60–7055
  • “You” for every “we”

    1.5 med 0.8

    0.2most 0.7–1.32.1

    Higher than most peers

  • Different asks in one email

    0 med 1

    0most 0–1.52
  • Subject length (characters)

    40 med 50

    31cut off on a phone near 41120

    Fewer than most peers

  • Images

    10 med 15

    6most 11–2531

    Fewer than most peers

  • Images with alt text

    40% med 39%

    0%100%
  • Links

    14 med 24

    14most 21–4757

    Fewer than most peers

  • Size

    32 KB med 78 KB

    22 KBGmail clips at 102 KB147 KB

    Lower than most peers

  • Spam signals

    0 med 1

    0most 0–12.5

What it does, against peers

Each figure is the share of peers that do it.

Does it, unlike most peers

  • Leads with a story 2 of 13
  • From a person at the organization 2 of 13
  • Signed by a person 3 of 13
  • Says why you got it 3 of 13

Skips it, unlike most peers

  • Has an open-tracking pixel 12 of 13
  • Subject cut off on a phone 11 of 13
  • From the organization’s name 11 of 13
  • Unsubscribe link in the email 11 of 13
  • Links are click-tracked 7 of 13

Skips it, like most peers

  • Invites people to an event 6 of 13
  • First button near the top 4 of 10
  • Asks people to take action 4 of 13
  • Reports results as numbers 4 of 13
  • Declares its language 4 of 13
  • Long enough that Gmail cuts it off 4 of 13
  • DMARC policy set to reject 4 of 13
  • Emoji in the subject 3 of 13
17 more
  • Reader’s name in the subject 3 of 13
  • Links carry campaign tags 3 of 13
  • Sent on a weekend 3 of 13
  • Asks people to volunteer 2 of 13
  • Subject is a question 2 of 13
  • Adjusts for dark mode 2 of 13
  • Donate link goes to a giving platform 1 of 8
  • Mentions planned giving 1 of 13
  • Preview spent on “View in browser” 1 of 13
  • Logo shown in the inbox (BIMI) 1 of 13
  • Broken personalization 0 of 13
  • Subject starts with “Re:” or “Fwd:” 0 of 13
  • Urgent wording in the subject 0 of 13
  • Almost all image 0 of 13
  • Has links without https 0 of 13
  • From a person’s name 0 of 13
  • Sent from a no-reply address 0 of 13
Does it, like most peers · 13 practices
  • DMARC policy turned on 7 of 13
  • Links to a donation page 8 of 13
  • Fits a phone screen 8 of 13
  • Has a button 10 of 13
  • Has preview text 10 of 13
  • Sent in the morning 10 of 13
  • Replies reach a real inbox 12 of 13
  • Postal address in the footer 12 of 13
  • Designed (HTML) rather than plain text 13 of 13
  • Includes a plain-text version 13 of 13
  • Signed with their own domain 13 of 13
  • One-click unsubscribe 13 of 13
  • Unsubscribe header 13 of 13