What we’re measuring in nonprofit email
Every email in the gallery is measured the same way: 87 things, from whether it has one-click unsubscribe to how long the subject runs. These are what the benchmarks are built from.
If you work on nonprofit email, we want your judgment. Tell us which of these matter, what good looks like, and what we should be measuring but aren’t. We’ll use it to decide what to add, and later to set expert targets beside the numbers.
You can weigh in anonymously. If you sign in and add your name, we’ll credit you when we publish those expert targets.
Weigh in, no sign-in needed
Rate as many or as few measures below as you like. Answers save as you go, in this browser. We don’t ask your name. Nothing rated yet.
Say what you do (optional)
It helps us weigh answers from people who work on email every day. Only we see it.
Get credit for your answers, or pick up on another device
Sign in
We’ll email you a link. No password. Anything you’ve already rated in this browser comes with you.
After signing up
Sent nothing in the first two weeks
Not even a welcome. Counted once a signup is 14 days old.
Across the gallery: 70% of organizations
Days from signup to first email
Across the gallery: 1 days
Asks new subscribers to confirm
Across the gallery: 25% of organizations
Emails in the first 30 days
Counted once a signup is 30 days old.
Across the gallery: 0
Emails a month
Across the gallery: 0
Days between emails
Each organization’s typical gap, among those that sent two or more.
Across the gallery: 6.6 days
Days to the first ask for money
Among organizations that have asked.
Across the gallery: 12.1 days
Asked for money in the first 30 days
Across the gallery: 12% of organizations
Emails that ask for money
Each organization’s share, among those with three or more emails.
Across the gallery: 30%
The mix of kinds of email an organization sends
Each organization’s share of newsletters, appeals, event invitations, action alerts, thank-yous, and welcomes.
Asks and calls to action
Has a button
Across the gallery: 55%
Buttons
Across the gallery: 1
First button near the top
Within the first 500 characters of text.
Across the gallery: 29%
Links to a donation page
Across the gallery: 46%
Names a dollar amount
Across the gallery: 26%
Offers suggested amounts
Across the gallery: 8%
Asks for a monthly gift
Across the gallery: 13%
Mentions a match
Across the gallery: 21%
Gives a deadline
Across the gallery: 41%
Suggested amounts offered
Among appeals that offer a ladder of amounts.
Across the gallery: 3
Lowest suggested amount
Across the gallery: $27
Highest suggested amount
Across the gallery: $100
Donate link goes to a giving platform
Among emails with a donate link: Classy, Givebutter, and the like, rather than the organization’s own site, when we can follow the link.
Across the gallery: 22%
Which giving platform the donate link uses
Classy, Givebutter, Donorbox, and about twenty more, when we can follow the link.
Event is in person
Among emails inviting the reader to an event. Hybrid events count as both.
Across the gallery: 71%
Event is online
Across the gallery: 34%
What kind of event it invites people to
Gala, run or walk, webinar, community event, tour, volunteer day, conference, or something else.
Volunteer opportunities listed
Among emails asking the reader to volunteer that list any.
Across the gallery: 1
Says how many volunteers are needed
Across the gallery: 5%
Event link goes to a ticketing platform
Among emails with an event link: Eventbrite, Zoom, OneCause, and the like.
Across the gallery: 17%
Which platform the event link uses
Eventbrite, Zoom, OneCause, and about seven more, when we can follow the link.
Volunteer link goes to a sign-up platform
Among emails with a volunteer link: SignUpGenius, VolunteerHub, and the like.
Across the gallery: 7%
Which platform volunteers sign up through
SignUpGenius, VolunteerHub, Galaxy Digital, and about seven more, when we can follow the link.
Asks people to volunteer
Across the gallery: 17%
Invites people to an event
Across the gallery: 29%
Asks people to take action
Across the gallery: 11%
Mentions planned giving
Across the gallery: 2%
Different asks in one email
Give, volunteer, take action, attend, leave a gift in a will: how many of these one email asks for.
Across the gallery: 1
Writing
Words
Across the gallery: 369
Reading ease
Flesch score. 60 to 70 reads like plain English; higher is easier.
Across the gallery: 43
“You” for every “we”
How often the reader is addressed, against how often the organization talks about itself.
Across the gallery: 1
Broken personalization
A merge tag left showing, like *|FNAME|*, or a greeting missing its name, like “Hi ,”.
Across the gallery: 0%
Leads with a story
Across the gallery: 26%
Reports results as numbers
Across the gallery: 21%
Signed by a person
Across the gallery: 26%
Subject line and preview
Subject length (characters)
Across the gallery: 42
Subject is a question
Across the gallery: 5%
Emoji in the subject
Across the gallery: 12%
Subject cut off on a phone
Longer than about 41 characters, roughly what a phone’s inbox shows.
Across the gallery: 49%
Preview spent on “View in browser”
The line an inbox shows under the subject, used up on boilerplate.
Across the gallery: 5%
Subject starts with “Re:” or “Fwd:”
On a first email, a reply prefix suggests a conversation that never happened.
Across the gallery: 0%
Urgent wording in the subject
Across the gallery: 4%
Reader’s name in the subject
Across the gallery: 3%
Has preview text
Across the gallery: 71%
Design and accessibility
Designed (HTML) rather than plain text
Across the gallery: 100%
Fits a phone screen
Across the gallery: 71%
Adjusts for dark mode
Across the gallery: 8%
Images
Across the gallery: 9.5
Images with alt text
What a screen reader, or an inbox that blocks images, says instead.
Across the gallery: 52%
Almost all image
Across the gallery: 4%
Declares its language
Across the gallery: 47%
Links
Across the gallery: 15
Size
Across the gallery: 48 KB
Includes a plain-text version
Some readers and filters use it; a missing one can count against an email.
Across the gallery: 100%
Has links without https
Across the gallery: 2%
Long enough that Gmail cuts it off
Gmail hides everything past 102 KB behind a link.
Across the gallery: 9%
Who it’s from
From the organization’s name
Across the gallery: 83%
From a person’s name
Across the gallery: 7%
From a person at the organization
Like “Jane at Oxfam” or “Katrina, 350.org.”
Across the gallery: 10%
Replies reach a real inbox
Not a no-reply, bounce, or email-platform address.
Across the gallery: 95%
Sent from a no-reply address
Across the gallery: 3%
Which email platform sends it
Mailchimp, Constant Contact, HubSpot, and about thirty more, as a share of organizations.
Deliverability and compliance
DMARC policy turned on
Quarantine or reject: mail that fails the domain’s checks is filtered or refused, not delivered.
Across the gallery: 55%
DMARC policy set to reject
Across the gallery: 27%
Logo shown in the inbox (BIMI)
A published BIMI record. Some inboxes show the sender’s logo beside verified mail.
Across the gallery: 4%
Signed with their own domain
Across the gallery: 97%
One-click unsubscribe
Gmail and Yahoo have required it from bulk senders since 2024.
Across the gallery: 90%
Unsubscribe header
Across the gallery: 92%
Unsubscribe link in the email
Across the gallery: 89%
Postal address in the footer
Required by CAN-SPAM for commercial email. Most nonprofit mail includes one anyway.
Across the gallery: 80%
Says why you got it
Across the gallery: 28%
Spam signals
Named things filters hold against an email. A count, not a prediction.
Across the gallery: 0.6
Links are click-tracked
Across the gallery: 72%
Has an open-tracking pixel
Across the gallery: 79%
Links carry campaign tags
Across the gallery: 22%
Sending habits
Sent on a weekend
Welcome emails aren’t counted: they go out when someone signs up.
Across the gallery: 10%
Sent in the morning
Between 5 a.m. and noon in the organization’s own time zone. Welcome emails aren’t counted.
Across the gallery: 48%
What’s missing
Something you’d look at in a nonprofit email that isn’t above. Add as many as you like.