How donors use AI to find nonprofits, and what to check
November 12, 2026 · 4 min read
A donor asks an AI assistant which animal rescues near them are worth supporting. The assistant answers in a paragraph and names three. Your organization isn't one of them, and your website never got a visit it could have lost. Understanding how donors use AI to find nonprofits starts with accepting that part of the search now happens somewhere you can't see.
Nobody can promise a method that puts you in those answers. What you can do is make sure nothing on your side is in the way, and that the facts about you are easy to find and say the same thing everywhere.
How donors use AI to find nonprofits, by the numbers
Chris Maddocks of Avalon Consulting, writing for Candid in September 2026, argues that donors increasingly use AI tools to research causes and charities, so many never reach a nonprofit's website, donation page, or newsletter signup. He reports three figures, each credited to another source:
- Global Web Index: nearly six million U.S. donors who give frequently now cite AI as a preferred tool for finding causes and charities.
- Blue State's November 2025 report: organic search traffic to nonprofit websites fell 35% in a year, while AI-referred traffic rose more than 1,000%.
- Similarweb: 68% of web searches end without a click to a nonprofit website.
Treat these as signs of direction. They come from large datasets, and your own traffic may look different. Look at your analytics for the last year before you decide how much any of it applies to you.
Check that you aren't blocking the door
Three checks cost nothing and take about an hour.
- Open your robots.txt file. It lives at your domain followed by /robots.txt. Candid's article advises making sure it isn't blocking AI crawlers you want reading your content. A line blocking everything is sometimes left behind from when the site was being built.
- Read your pages as plain text. Candid's piece recommends clear headings and question-and-answer formats on program and impact pages, and warns against relying on heavy scripting or content that exists only as an image. If your hours, address, and programs are inside a picture, put them in words as well.
- Ask the assistants yourself. Type the question a donor would type, such as "where can I donate to a food pantry in" followed by your town. Note whether you appear and whether what's said about you is correct. Do it on two or three assistants, and write the date down.
Say a small food pantry runs this test and finds that an assistant lists last year's hours. The pantry's own site says the new hours only in a flyer image. Typing them into the page is a 10-minute fix, and it is the kind of change you can check by asking again in a month.
Make the facts about you agree everywhere
Maddocks also advises treating press coverage, community discussion, and third-party listings, including Candid's profile, as part of how you show up. The practical version is a one-page list of your name, address, phone, mission sentence, and the link you want people to use to give. Compare it with your website, your social profiles, and any directory listing. Where they differ, correct the outdated one.
The file called llms.txt is a plain page meant to tell AI tools what matters on a site. Whether any given assistant reads it is not something we can promise, and you shouldn't spend a week on it. It is a small file, and whether you have one is easy to check.
What to leave alone
Be careful with anyone who offers a guaranteed placement in AI answers. No one controls what an assistant says. Be careful too about putting donor details into any AI tool while you experiment. Donor data and AI tools covers what should never be entered.
The website scan checks the points above from the outside: whether AI search tools can read your site, whether you have an llms.txt file, and whether your donate and volunteer links load. It takes a few seconds. It's free, and there is no paid version. A deeper check, with a verified email, also looks at whether your organization comes up when someone asks an AI where to donate or volunteer.
Pick the one fact on your list that is wrong somewhere, and correct it. The next donor who asks will be answered from whatever is there.