Questions to ask an AI vendor before your nonprofit signs up
November 21, 2026 · 3 min read
A program manager finds an AI tool that drafts case summaries and wants to try it on Monday. The sign-up page asks for an email address and a credit card number, and nobody has read the terms. These are the questions to ask an AI vendor before anyone enters a name, a donor record, or a client note, and most of them take one email to answer.
Start with what you intend to put in
Candid's January 2026 post on responsible AI use policies, by Meena Das, tells staff not to enter sensitive information: personally identifying or confidential information, legal documents, and passwords, or anything you wouldn't paste into a public website. Use that as your test for the vendor too. Before you ask anything, write down the most sensitive thing someone will plausibly paste in. That tells you how hard to press.
If the answer is "a draft thank-you letter with no names," the stakes are low and a short review is enough. If it's client notes or donor gift histories, treat the questions below as required. Donor data and AI tools goes through what should never go in.
Five questions to ask an AI vendor
Candid's 2022 post on grantee data protection, by Laia Griñó, offers questions written for a grants system that carry over directly. It asks whether data is encrypted, who outside the organization has access to it, and whether vendors have sufficient data protection practices. Build on those.
- Is what we enter used to train your models, and can we turn that off? The answer should be written down in the terms or a help page, not given on a call.
- Who outside your company can see our data? Look for named categories, such as hosting providers, not "trusted partners."
- Is our data encrypted, and where is it stored? You're not auditing them. You're checking they can answer in a sentence.
- What happens when we delete something, or leave? Ask whether deletion covers backups and how long it takes.
- Does the free or low-cost plan have the same terms as the business plan? Terms often differ by plan, and staff sign up on whichever is easiest.
Keep the answers in one shared document with the date you asked. If the vendor won't answer in writing, that is an answer.
Who needs to say yes
Decide who approves a tool before staff find one. At a small nonprofit that's often the executive director for low-risk uses and the board chair or a designated board member when donor or client data is involved. Say the approval is two lines in a document: the tool, the kind of data allowed, and who approved it.
Candid's grantee-data post also asks whether staff are familiar with your policies and have received adequate training. A vendor can be fine and your staff still paste the wrong thing in. AI training for nonprofit staff covers that side.
Check what's already switched on
Many tools your staff already use have added AI features. Run the five questions against the email platform, the donor database, and the note-taking app too. Some answers will surprise you, and the board is better off hearing that from you than from a donor.
If you want to see where your board and staff stand before choosing tools, the AI readiness assessment takes about seven minutes each and can go to the board, the staff, or both. The report shows where the two groups agree and where they don't, and it doesn't push you to adopt anything. It's free, and there's no paid version.
One email to a vendor takes 10 minutes to write and may save you a hard conversation with a donor. If you sign up, put the date and the answers in the same place you keep your policy.