Volunteer exit interview: a three-question script
November 21, 2026 · 3 min read
A volunteer who has been coming every Tuesday for two years sends a short note saying she's stepping back. You write back warmly, thank her, and never learn why. A volunteer exit interview is the cheap way to find out, and it's one of the few chances you get to hear from someone who no longer has a reason to be polite.
Why the people who leave know things the people who stay don't
Candid's Insights blog, in a February 2025 post by David Close of the University of Tennessee Extension, cites AmeriCorps figures: the average annual volunteer retention rate under "normal" circumstances is only 65%, and volunteers typically stay with an organization for fewer than three years. Say you have 40 volunteers. At 65%, about 14 of them won't be back next year, and each one has a reason.
Current volunteers tend to tell a coordinator what's easy to say. People who are leaving have less to protect. A sample exit interview from Volunteer Ireland makes the same point, noting that volunteers may be more frank once they've finished. That's the argument for asking at the end, in addition to whatever you ask during the year.
A three-question volunteer exit interview
Volunteer Ireland's sample template runs to 10 questions, including a checklist of reasons for leaving. That's a fine starting point, but a volunteer who is already halfway out the door will give you more on three questions than on ten. Try these.
- What led to your decision to stop? Let them answer in their own words before you offer a list. Reasons like a new job, a move, or a health issue are common and not a verdict on you. Write them down anyway, because a pattern across several people is information.
- What was different from what you expected when you started? This is where vague roles, a thin first shift, and unclear next steps show up. The answers point at the first month of volunteering, which is where most programs can change the most.
- Is there anything we could have done that would have changed your mind? Sometimes the answer is nothing. Sometimes it's "I asked twice to switch to Saturdays and nobody answered." You can fix the second kind.
End by thanking them for specific work. "You ran the sign-in table for two winters" lands better than "we appreciate your service."
Who asks, and how
Pick a person who wasn't the volunteer's direct supervisor. If the answer to question two is "my supervisor was hard to reach," asking the supervisor won't produce it. At a small organization that may mean a board member or a second coordinator doing a 15-minute phone call.
Offer a choice of a call or a short written form, and say plainly that answering is optional. Say too what you'll do with the answers: you'll read them for patterns, and you won't pass individual comments to the person's supervisor unless the volunteer says that's fine. Then keep that promise.
What to do with the answers
Keep a one-page sheet with a row per departure, a column per question, and the reason sorted into a few groups: life changes, role problems, communication problems, and other. After six or eight interviews, look at which group is largest. Say that three of your eight leavers mention not hearing back about schedule changes. That's a single fix, and it's a better use of an hour than another thank-you event.
Share the pattern, not the transcripts, with whoever manages volunteers. Volunteer retention covers the first-month fixes in more detail, and volunteer survey questions covers how to ask the people who are still here.
If you want a way to hear from current volunteers, the volunteer experience survey takes them about four minutes each, the coordinator runs it, answers are anonymous, and it's free with no paid version. It sits alongside an exit conversation. Neither replaces the other.
You won't get a useful answer from everyone, and that's fine. One honest conversation a quarter, written down, will tell you more about your program than a year of guessing.