Nonprofit email benchmarks

All kinds of email · Civil rights and advocacy · $2 million to $10 million · Midwest

8 organizations, 100 emails. Read them

This group on top, all nonprofits beneath, on a shared scale. The measures that differ most come first.

This group, middle halfAll nonprofits, middle halfFull rangeMedian

  • Design and accessibility

    Size

    17 KB

    0 KB394 KB

    vs 48 KB for all nonprofits

    0.3× the median

  • Design and accessibility

    Images

    5.4

    057

    vs 9.5 for all nonprofits

    4.1 fewer

  • Writing

    “You” for every “we”

    1.6

    010.8

    vs 1 for all nonprofits

    0.6 higher

  • Design and accessibility

    Links

    9.9

    084

    vs 15 for all nonprofits

    0.7× the median

  • Writing

    Reading ease

    48

    -169

    vs 43 for all nonprofits

    5 higher

  • After signing up

    Emails a month

    2.2

    058.2

    vs 0 for all nonprofits

    2.2 higher

  • After signing up

    Days to the first ask for money

    5.1 days

    0 days4 organizations, too few for a range42.4 days

    vs 12.1 days for all nonprofits

    0.4× the median

  • After signing up

    Emails in the first 30 days

    2

    063

    vs 0 for all nonprofits

    2 more

  • Asks and calls to action

    Different asks in one email

    0.8

    03

    vs 1 for all nonprofits

    0.2 fewer

  • Deliverability and compliance

    Spam signals

    0.4

    05.5

    vs 0.6 for all nonprofits

    About the same

  • After signing up

    Days from signup to first email

    0 days

    0 days42.4 days

    vs 1 days for all nonprofits

    About the same

  • Writing

    Words

    347

    133306

    vs 369 for all nonprofits

    About the same

  • Asks and calls to action

    Buttons

    0.8

    027

    vs 1 for all nonprofits

    About the same

  • After signing up

    Days between emails

    6 days

    0 days41.5 days

    vs 6.6 days for all nonprofits

    About the same

  • Subject line and preview

    Subject length (characters)

    42

    10132

    vs 42 for all nonprofits

    About the same

How common each practice is

The share of organizations that usually do each of these.

This groupAll nonprofits

After signing up

  • Sent nothing in the first two weeks6 of 14 organizations

    Not even a welcome. Counted once a signup is 14 days old.

    All nonprofits: 70%

  • Asks new subscribers to confirm1 of 8 organizations

    All nonprofits: 25%

  • Asked for money in the first 30 days4 of 14 organizations

    All nonprofits: 12%

  • Emails that ask for money24%

    Each organization’s share, among those with three or more emails.

    All nonprofits: 30%

  • The mix of kinds of email an organization sends

    Each organization’s share of newsletters, appeals, event invitations, action alerts, thank-yous, and welcomes.

    This group

    Newsletters and updates 12% · Event invitations 6%

    All nonprofits

    Welcome emails 12% · Advocacy and action alerts 4% · Event invitations 14% · Thank-yous and stewardship 2%

Asks and calls to action

  • Has a button4 of 8 organizations

    All nonprofits: 55%

  • First button near the top1 of 4 organizations

    Within the first 500 characters of text.

    All nonprofits: 29%

  • Links to a donation page5 of 8 organizations

    All nonprofits: 46%

  • Names a dollar amount0 of 4 organizations

    All nonprofits: 26%

  • Offers suggested amounts0 of 4 organizations

    All nonprofits: 8%

  • Asks for a monthly gift0 of 4 organizations

    All nonprofits: 13%

  • Mentions a match0 of 4 organizations

    All nonprofits: 21%

  • Gives a deadline0 of 4 organizations

    All nonprofits: 41%

  • Donate link goes to a giving platform3 of 6 organizations

    Among emails with a donate link: Classy, Givebutter, and the like, rather than the organization’s own site, when we can follow the link.

    All nonprofits: 22%

  • Event is in person2 of 5 organizations

    Among emails inviting the reader to an event. Hybrid events count as both.

    All nonprofits: 71%

  • Event is online3 of 5 organizations

    All nonprofits: 34%

  • Says how many volunteers are needed0 of 1 organizations

    All nonprofits: 5%

  • Event link goes to a ticketing platform0 of 5 organizations

    Among emails with an event link: Eventbrite, Zoom, OneCause, and the like.

    All nonprofits: 17%

  • Volunteer link goes to a sign-up platform0 of 2 organizations

    Among emails with a volunteer link: SignUpGenius, VolunteerHub, and the like.

    All nonprofits: 7%

  • Asks people to volunteer1 of 8 organizations

    All nonprofits: 17%

  • Invites people to an event2 of 8 organizations

    All nonprofits: 29%

  • Asks people to take action1 of 8 organizations

    All nonprofits: 11%

  • Mentions planned giving0 of 8 organizations

    All nonprofits: 2%

  • Which giving platform the donate link uses

    Classy, Givebutter, Donorbox, and about twenty more, when we can follow the link.

    This group

    All nonprofits

    Action Network 5% · Network for Good 4% · Qgiv 11% · Blackbaud 12% · DonorPerfect 6% · GoFundMe 3% · Give Lively 2% · Givebutter 2% · Kindful 2% · Neon 2% · PayPal 2% · Classy 2% · six others at 1% or less

  • What kind of event it invites people to

    Gala, run or walk, webinar, community event, tour, volunteer day, conference, or something else.

    This group

    Gala or benefit 8%

    All nonprofits

    Gala or benefit 11% · Community event 14% · Conference 3% · Run, walk, or ride 2% · one other at 1% or less

Writing

  • Broken personalization0 of 8 organizations

    A merge tag left showing, like *|FNAME|*, or a greeting missing its name, like “Hi ,”.

    All nonprofits: 0%

  • Leads with a story3 of 8 organizations

    All nonprofits: 26%

  • Reports results as numbers0 of 8 organizations

    All nonprofits: 21%

  • Signed by a person2 of 8 organizations

    All nonprofits: 26%

Subject line and preview

  • Subject is a question0 of 8 organizations

    All nonprofits: 5%

  • Emoji in the subject0 of 8 organizations

    All nonprofits: 12%

  • Subject cut off on a phone4 of 8 organizations

    Longer than about 41 characters, roughly what a phone’s inbox shows.

    All nonprofits: 49%

  • Preview spent on “View in browser”0 of 8 organizations

    The line an inbox shows under the subject, used up on boilerplate.

    All nonprofits: 5%

  • Subject starts with “Re:” or “Fwd:”0 of 8 organizations

    On a first email, a reply prefix suggests a conversation that never happened.

    All nonprofits: 0%

  • Urgent wording in the subject0 of 8 organizations

    All nonprofits: 4%

  • Reader’s name in the subject0 of 8 organizations

    All nonprofits: 3%

  • Has preview text5 of 8 organizations

    All nonprofits: 71%

Design and accessibility

  • Designed (HTML) rather than plain text8 of 8 organizations

    All nonprofits: 100%

  • Fits a phone screen7 of 8 organizations

    All nonprofits: 71%

  • Adjusts for dark mode3 of 8 organizations

    All nonprofits: 8%

  • Images with alt text70%

    What a screen reader, or an inbox that blocks images, says instead.

    All nonprofits: 52%

  • Almost all image1 of 8 organizations

    All nonprofits: 4%

  • Declares its language7 of 8 organizations

    All nonprofits: 47%

  • Includes a plain-text version8 of 8 organizations

    Some readers and filters use it; a missing one can count against an email.

    All nonprofits: 100%

  • Has links without https0 of 8 organizations

    All nonprofits: 2%

  • Long enough that Gmail cuts it off0 of 8 organizations

    Gmail hides everything past 102 KB behind a link.

    All nonprofits: 9%

Who it’s from

  • From the organization’s name7 of 8 organizations

    All nonprofits: 83%

  • From a person’s name0 of 8 organizations

    All nonprofits: 7%

  • From a person at the organization1 of 8 organizations

    Like “Jane at Oxfam” or “Katrina, 350.org.”

    All nonprofits: 10%

  • Replies reach a real inbox7 of 8 organizations

    Not a no-reply, bounce, or email-platform address.

    All nonprofits: 95%

  • Sent from a no-reply address0 of 8 organizations

    All nonprofits: 3%

  • Which email platform sends it

    Mailchimp, Constant Contact, HubSpot, and about thirty more, as a share of organizations.

    This group

    All nonprofits

    Action Network 1% · Bloomerang 5% · EveryAction 5% · Constant Contact 25% · Amazon SES 5% · Salesforce Account Engagement 4% · HubSpot 3% · Campaign Monitor 2% · 16 others at 1% or less

Deliverability and compliance

  • DMARC policy turned on5 of 8 organizations

    Quarantine or reject: mail that fails the domain’s checks is filtered or refused, not delivered.

    All nonprofits: 55%

  • DMARC policy set to reject1 of 8 organizations

    All nonprofits: 27%

  • Logo shown in the inbox (BIMI)0 of 8 organizations

    A published BIMI record. Some inboxes show the sender’s logo beside verified mail.

    All nonprofits: 4%

  • Signed with their own domain8 of 8 organizations

    All nonprofits: 97%

  • One-click unsubscribe7 of 8 organizations

    Gmail and Yahoo have required it from bulk senders since 2024.

    All nonprofits: 90%

  • Unsubscribe header8 of 8 organizations

    All nonprofits: 92%

  • Unsubscribe link in the email7 of 8 organizations

    All nonprofits: 89%

  • Postal address in the footer5 of 8 organizations

    Required by CAN-SPAM for commercial email. Most nonprofit mail includes one anyway.

    All nonprofits: 80%

  • Says why you got it4 of 8 organizations

    All nonprofits: 28%

  • Links are click-tracked3 of 8 organizations

    All nonprofits: 72%

  • Has an open-tracking pixel4 of 8 organizations

    All nonprofits: 79%

  • Links carry campaign tags0 of 8 organizations

    All nonprofits: 22%

Sending habits

  • Sent on a weekend1 of 8 organizations

    Welcome emails aren’t counted: they go out when someone signs up.

    All nonprofits: 10%

  • Sent in the morning4 of 8 organizations

    Between 5 a.m. and noon in the organization’s own time zone. Welcome emails aren’t counted.

    All nonprofits: 48%

Rows about the ask (dollar amounts, matches, deadlines) count fundraising appeals only.

By kind of email

GroupOrganizationsWordsHas a buttonOne-click unsubscribeFits a phone screen
Other62073 of 65 of 64 of 6
Welcome62044 of 64 of 64 of 6
Newsletter or update55352 of 55 of 55 of 5
Advocacy or action alert4Needs 5 organizations
Event invitation4Needs 5 organizations
Fundraising appeal4Needs 5 organizations
Re-engagement1Needs 5 organizations

How these are measured

Most measures are read directly from the email: its HTML, its headers, and the verdicts our mail server records when it arrives. The kind of email, the shape of its ask, and whether it leads with a story are read by a language model and can be wrong on any single email. Budget and focus area come from IRS filings.

Each organization counts once, at its typical email, however many it sent. Counts like words and buttons are drawn as range strips: the line runs from the lowest organization to the highest, the band is the middle half, and the tick is the median. A measure with fewer than 5 organizations shows its median alone. Shares are of organizations; in a group of fewer than 20 they read as a count, like “3 of 5 organizations,” because a percentage of a handful looks more precise than it is.

A group needs 5 organizations before its numbers are shown. These numbers are updated every hour.

See every measure in plain words. If you work on nonprofit email, you can tell us which ones matter and what we’re missing.