An emergency succession plan for a small nonprofit
October 29, 2026 · 6 min read
If your executive director were in a car accident tonight, who would run payroll on Friday? Who knows the password to the bank account, the donor database, and the website? Who would call your largest funder, and what would they say? At most small nonprofits the honest answer to all three is the executive director. An emergency succession plan is one page that gives every one of those questions a different answer, written down before anyone needs it.
It's one of the cheapest things a board can do, and one of the most commonly skipped, usually because it feels morbid or because the director seems indestructible.
An emergency succession plan is not a succession plan
The two get confused, and the confusion is why boards put this off. A succession plan in the usual sense is about the next permanent leader: developing people, planning a search, handling a planned retirement. It's long-range, it's sensitive, and plenty of boards reasonably decide it isn't urgent.
An emergency succession plan covers the first 30 to 90 days after the director is suddenly unavailable, for any reason. Illness, an accident, a family crisis, a sudden resignation. It doesn't decide who the next director is. It keeps the organization running, legally and financially, while the board works out what happens next.
What goes on the one page
Five things, and each one fits in a short paragraph.
Who acts. Name an acting executive director and a backup. At an organization with staff, this is usually the most senior staff member. At an organization where the director is the only paid staff, it's usually a board officer, most often the chair or vice chair. A board member stepping into the role is stepping into management, so the plan should say it's temporary and the board should record it when it happens.
What they're allowed to do. Pass a board resolution now that gives the acting director authority to approve payroll, pay bills, and sign routine contracts up to a stated amount. Anything larger goes to the executive committee or the full board. Without this, a capable acting director can't legally do much of anything, and the bank won't care how capable they are.
Who can get into what. Make a list of every account the organization depends on: the bank and online banking, payroll, the accounting software, the donor database, the email administrator, the website and the domain registrar, social media, grant portals, and insurance. The page doesn't hold the passwords. It says where they're kept, such as a password manager with emergency access set up, or a sealed envelope the chair holds. Put at least two people other than the director on the bank's signature card now, not after the emergency. The domain registrar is the one everyone forgets, and losing it takes the website and the email down with it.
Who tells whom, and when. The chair tells the board within a day. The chair and the acting director tell staff together, in person if possible. Within a week, the chair calls the two or three funders who matter most, before they hear it some other way. Everyone else gets a short, plain note. The plan should also say what not to share: medical and family details belong to the director and their family, and "is on leave" is enough.
When it becomes a search. Decide in advance the point at which the board stops waiting. A common choice is 90 days, or immediately if the director isn't coming back. At that point the board decides between an interim director and a search, and the nonprofit board roles and responsibilities that apply in ordinary times apply with more weight.
An invented example: a seven-person literacy organization names its program director as acting director and the board treasurer as backup. The resolution lets the acting director approve payroll and spending up to $5,000. Two board officers are on the bank account. The password manager has emergency access granted to the chair. The page took one meeting to draft and one to approve.
Keeping the plan current
A plan written once and filed goes stale within a year. People leave, accounts change, and the backup moved away.
Review it once a year, at the same meeting as the executive director performance review, so it has a fixed date and nobody has to remember it. Then test one thing each year. Can the second signer actually log in to online banking? Does the chair know how to use the emergency access to the password manager? Is the acting director still the right person? A plan nobody has tried is a plan that fails at the first locked door.
The National Council of Nonprofits and most state associations publish succession planning resources if you want templates. The one page described here is enough to start.
Talking about it with the executive director
Some directors hear "emergency succession plan" as "replacement plan," and it's worth saying plainly that it isn't. It protects the director's work as much as the organization. If they're out for six weeks, they come back to an organization that kept going, not to one that stalled or made emergency decisions without them.
The director should draft most of it, because the director is the one who knows where everything is. That's also the best test of whether the organization depends too heavily on one person. A director who can't or won't write down where the passwords are is telling the board something, and it's often an early sign of founder's syndrome rather than a passing reluctance.
The executive director review asks both the board and the director whether a written plan exists for who would lead if the director were suddenly unavailable, and board members answer separately from the director. A board that's sure there's a plan and a director who has never seen one find that out before it matters. It's free, and there's no paid version of it.
Pick a date at the next meeting, ask the director for a first draft, and put the approved page somewhere at least three people can find it. That's the whole job, and it's done.