← All guides

Executive director goals a board can actually review

October 29, 2026 · 6 min read

Ask a board chair what the executive director's goals were last year and you'll usually get a pause, then a description of the budget. The budget is a plan for the organization. Executive director goals are something narrower: the four to six things the board and the director agreed would matter most this year, written down, so that 12 months later both of them can say what happened against each one without arguing about what was meant.

Most small boards have never set them. That isn't negligence so much as habit. The director was hired to run the place, the board meets every other month, and writing the goals down is nobody's job in particular. The cost shows up at review time, when the only standard available is how everyone feels.

What makes executive director goals reviewable

A goal is reviewable if two people who disagree about how the year went can still agree on whether it was met. That's the whole test, and four things usually get you there.

It says what done looks like. "Strengthen fundraising" can't be met or missed. "Raise $40,000 from individual donors, up from $28,000" can. Not every goal has a number, but every goal has a finished state: the plan approved, the hire made, the report delivered.

It has a date. "By the September board meeting" is a date. "This year" is barely one, and it's how goals drift into the following year without anyone deciding that they should.

It's mostly within the director's control. A goal that depends on a funder's decision is a hope. Write it around what the director can actually do: submit three proposals of a certain size, rather than win them.

There are only a few. Four to six. A list of 15 is a job description with dates on it, and at review time the board will skim it and talk about impressions anyway.

Here's an invented example, for a small food bank. Hire and onboard a warehouse coordinator by March. Close the fiscal year within 3% of budget. Bring the board a two-year plan for a second distribution site by the October meeting. Grow individual giving from 120 donors to 160. Notice what's missing: nothing about attitude, presence, or "leadership." Those matter, and a review gets at them other ways. Goals are for the work.

Who writes them, and when

The director drafts them. The chair, or whoever is on the review committee, reads the draft, pushes on it, and agrees a final version with the director. Then the full board sees the list, and it goes in the minutes. A goal the board never formally saw is hard to hold anyone to, and it's just as hard for the director to point to when the board later complains about something that was never on the list.

The best time is right after the annual review, or at the start of the fiscal year if the two are close together. The review has just told everyone what the year looked like, so the conversation about next year starts from something real.

The director drafting is not a formality. They know what's feasible, and goals the director wrote are goals they believe in. The board's job is to check that the list reflects the board's priorities too, and that nothing on it quietly assumes help the board hasn't agreed to give. If a goal needs the board to find three people for a campaign committee, say so in writing, next to the goal.

Evaluating the chief executive is one of the basic duties BoardSource lists for every nonprofit board. Written goals are what make that duty something a board can actually carry out, rather than a feeling it has once a year.

Setting goals for the first time, partway through a year

Most boards reading this aren't at the start of a fiscal year. That's fine. Don't wait for a clean start.

Write goals for the months that are left, and label them plainly as a partial year. Pick three or four things that will clearly be done or not done by year end. At the next review you'll have something to review, and the year after you can set a full list at the right time.

If you're reviewing the executive director now and there were no goals, say so without apology and review the year anyway. An executive director performance review can still cover what happened, how the board and the director each see the work, and what the board itself did to help or get in the way. It just can't measure against a standard nobody set. The most useful thing a first review produces is often the goals for the second one.

How this year's review sets next year's goals

A review that ends with "good year, thanks" and no goals has done half its job. Close every review by turning what you learned into the next list.

  • A goal that was partly met usually belongs on next year's list, rewritten so it can be finished.
  • A goal that was missed for reasons outside the director's control should be reshaped or dropped, not repeated in hope.
  • Where the board and the director saw part of the work very differently, there's often a goal hiding in the gap. Not "be better at board communication," but "send a one-page financial summary with every board packet." The gap itself is worth looking at first, which is why scoring the chief executive separately matters.
  • If the review turned up something the board owes the director, such as donor introductions or a decision that has been pending for a year, write that down too. Goals run both ways, and plenty of missed goals trace back to the board.

Keep goals and pay in separate conversations, even in the same month. Pay has its own process and its own paperwork, covered in setting executive director compensation, and mixing the two turns a goal-setting meeting into a negotiation.

Then check in once at mid-year. Not a second review, just a 20-minute item on the board meeting agenda: here are the goals, here's where each one stands, does anything need to change. A goal that turns out to be wrong in June should be changed in June, on the record, not discovered to be wrong in December.

Putting the goals into the review

The executive director review takes up to five goals at setup, in your own words, and asks board members and the director separately how each one went: met, partly met, not met, or too early to tell. Goals are optional. If you don't have any yet, it runs without them, and it asks both the board and the director what next year's goals should be, so a first review gives you the list for the second. It's free, and there's no paid version of it.

Four or five sentences on one page, agreed in a meeting and written into the minutes, is all this takes. The hard part is writing them before you need them, while everyone still remembers what they meant.

Executive director review

Review your executive director with the whole board

Board members answer in private, the director answers their own version, and staff can add their view if you have five or more. The committee gets a short report to read and then share with the director. It's free, and there is no paid version.

Related guides