How many Giving Tuesday emails to send, and what each says
November 3, 2026 · 7 min read
Someone on the board has forwarded a Giving Tuesday email from a much larger organization, with one line on top: should we be doing this? You have four weeks, a list of a few hundred people, and a year-end appeal that already needs writing. The real question isn't whether to send Giving Tuesday emails. It's how few you can send and still do the job, and whether this is the year to send any at all.
This year the day falls on December 1, the Tuesday after Thanksgiving, according to GivingTuesday's own site. Four weeks is enough for a short plan and not for an elaborate one.
First, decide whether to take part
Giving Tuesday is one day, and for most donors it isn't the day they give. A 2025 special report from the Blackbaud Institute and GivingTuesday, drawn from Blackbaud's own donor data, found that only 2.4% of all donors in 2024 gave on Giving Tuesday. Your supporters will still give in December. The question is whether a campaign on the 1st brings in gifts you wouldn't otherwise get, or moves a few of them three weeks earlier and costs you a week of writing.
There's an argument the other way. Woodrow Rosenbaum, GivingTuesday's chief data officer, wrote for Candid in 2025 that small, community-based organizations benefit most from the day, because it raises awareness of local groups. He runs research for the day itself, so take that as an argument rather than a finding. It still asks the right question: will anyone new hear about you that day?
Three questions settle most of it:
- Do you have something that makes the day different? A board member or a local business willing to match gifts up to a set amount, or a specific thing the money buys by a specific date. "Please give on Giving Tuesday" is not a reason. "Every gift today is doubled" is.
- Can you do it without taking hours from the year-end appeal? If one person does all of your fundraising, the year-end appeal is the one you can't afford to rush.
- Will anyone besides you share it? Board members forwarding the launch to their friends is how a small organization reaches people not already on its list.
If the answer to all three is no, skip it. Use Thanksgiving week for a short note with no ask in it, saying what this year's gifts did, and put your effort into December. Sitting out a crowded day costs very little. Rushing the appeal that follows it can cost more.
The five Giving Tuesday emails worth sending
If you do take part, the instinct is to fill the day with an email every few hours and a midnight countdown. Every one of them draws on the same goodwill, and how often people want to hear from you is worth asking your supporters directly rather than guessing. A short sequence where each email has one job asks less of your list and less of you.
The examples below are for an invented food pantry whose board treasurer has offered to match gifts up to $2,000.
The save-the-date, the week before
This one tells people the day is coming and why it matters to you this year. There's no ask in it, or at most a quiet link. Send it the Tuesday before Thanksgiving, before people leave for the holiday.
Example: "Next Tuesday, our treasurer will match every gift up to $2,000, and we'll write that morning to tell you what it buys."
The launch, on the morning of the day
This is the ask. One thing the money does, one amount, one button, short enough to read on a phone in line for coffee. The rest can wait for the thank-you.
Example: "Today every gift to the pantry is doubled, up to $2,000, and $40 covers a family's groceries for a week."
One reminder, in the afternoon
This one reports progress against the match and what's left. It goes only to people who haven't given yet.
Example: "We're at $1,150 of the $2,000 match, so $850 is still waiting to be doubled."
The last-hours note, in the evening
This one is the deadline and nothing else: three sentences and a button, sent early enough that someone on the couch still has time to act.
Example: "The match ends at midnight, and we're $300 short of it."
The thank-you, within two days
This one goes to everyone who gave, with the result and what happens next. In a 2024 piece for Candid, Celeste Flores and Samir Khan of GivingTuesday suggest a handwritten note soon after the gift as well, and a thank-you call from a board member. A thank-you call is also the easiest fundraising job you can hand a board member who dreads asking, and it's worth writing into what the board is expected to do on fundraising.
Example: "Yesterday 61 of you met the $2,000 match, and here is what the pantry is buying first."
Who to leave off the list
Three groups need handling before you press send.
- People who gave today. Take them off the reminder and the last-hours note. Unless your donation form and your email tool already talk to each other, someone checks the donation report before each send and removes the names by hand. It's tedious. Do it anyway.
- People who gave in the last few weeks. Someone who gave at your fall event or mailed a check last week can get a version of the launch that thanks them first and asks only that they forward it.
- People who never asked to hear from you. An event sign-in sheet or a board member's address book is not a mailing list.
Leaving donors off the rest of the day isn't the same as leaving them off for good. The same Blackbaud Institute and GivingTuesday report found that 65% of Giving Tuesday donors gave again, against 52% of donors overall. That's an argument for treating them well in December, not for asking them twice in a week.
How Giving Tuesday fits with the year-end appeal
Flores and Khan describe Giving Tuesday as the start of year-end fundraising and argue against treating it as an add-on. In practice that means one campaign with two moments, not two campaigns that happen to share a month.
Start by counting. Five Giving Tuesday emails, a year-end appeal in mid-December, and two follow-ups in the last days of the year make eight emails in five weeks, six of them asks. Put them on one page before you write the first. If the number makes you wince, drop the save-the-date and the reminder, because the launch, the last-hours note, and the thank-you carry most of the weight.
Then leave a gap. Flores and Khan warn against letting another ask be the next time a donor hears from you, so let a week or so pass after the thank-you before the next ask.
Finally, write the year-end appeal in two versions. People who gave on Giving Tuesday get one that opens with their gift and what it did, then asks whether they'd like to give once more before the year closes. Everyone else gets the full appeal. Only the first paragraph changes, and it tells a donor you noticed.
To see how other nonprofits handle this before you write your own, the email gallery's benchmarks show how long nonprofit appeals run and how many name a dollar amount, broken out by kind of email, focus area, budget, and region. Each email in the gallery is measured the same way, and it's free to browse. Reading three or four real appeals next to your draft is a quick way to see whether yours is longer than it needs to be.
Five emails is a ceiling, not a target. If what you can manage this year is a launch, a thank-you, and a careful year-end appeal, that's a plan. Your list will get a lot of email on December 1. Yours doesn't have to be the loudest. It can be the one that said one thing each time and wrote back afterward to say what the money did.