← All guides

How to write a year-end appeal email

November 9, 2026 · 4 min read

You have a list of 400 people, a December you can't extend, and a draft that begins "As we approach the end of another year." That sentence tells the reader nothing, and they will stop at it. A year-end appeal email works when it sounds like one person writing to another about one thing, and it fails when it sounds like an organization addressing a mailing list.

This is a plan for writing one, start to finish, without a development department.

Pick one thing the money does

Before you write a word, finish this sentence: "Gifts this month will pay for ___." It should be specific and small enough that a reader can picture it. "Our work" doesn't count. "Winter coats for 60 children in the after-school program" does, even for an invented example like that one.

If you have a deadline or a match, say so once, plainly. If you don't, don't make one up. A real reason to give in December is that your year ends there. A manufactured one is a countdown clock on a Tuesday in the middle of the month.

Write the year-end appeal email from a person

Pick a name for the sender. The executive director, the board chair, or a volunteer who has been there for years all work, and the signature at the bottom should match the sender in the inbox. People answer a person. A line that says "info@" is easy to ignore.

Keep it short. Ashley Halsey, writing for Candid in 2020, recommends about three paragraphs, since many readers skim, and a subject line preferably under 60 characters that is accurate about what's inside. Her advice is to make the call to action clear and to explain it early in the email text.

A workable shape:

  1. Open with a moment. One concrete scene or one result from this year. Two sentences.
  2. Say what you're asking for. One sentence naming the thing and one amount that is reasonable.
  3. Give the button. One link, to one page. Check it from your phone first. If the page needs work, start with the donate page.
  4. Add a P.S. The deadline, or the match, in a sentence.

Plan the follow-ups before the first send

One email is rarely the whole appeal. Candid's Krista Berry wrote in 2022 that up to 31% of online year-end giving happens in December and about 10% in the last three days of the year. She suggests pre-scheduling touchpoints after the appeal goes out so they continue through December 31. Those are Candid's numbers, so use them as a reason to plan the last week and not as a prediction for your list.

For a small list, a reasonable plan is three emails: the appeal in early or mid-December, a short reminder to people who haven't given, and a last note in the final days. If you took part in Giving Tuesday, the Giving Tuesday emails show how the two plans fit.

Leave people off the list when they shouldn't be on it. Anyone who gave since the appeal doesn't get the reminder. Anyone who asked to be removed stays removed. The tedious part is checking the donation report before each send.

Write the thank-you at the same time

Draft the thank-you before you send the appeal. It's the email people remember, and it's the one most likely to be skipped when December gets busy. A donation thank-you email covers what it needs to say. Send it within a day or two of the gift, from the same person who signed the appeal.

Compare your draft with real appeals

Reading three or four real appeals next to your draft shows you quickly whether yours is too long or buries the ask. The email gallery shows nonprofit appeals measured the same way, and its benchmarks break out length and other features by kind of email, focus area, budget, and region. It's free to browse. Use it to check your draft, not to copy one.

Send the appeal when it is ready and short enough to read on a phone. A plain email from a named person, with one clear request and a link that works, will do the job a longer one tries to do.

Email gallery

See what other nonprofits send their supporters

Real appeals, newsletters, and event invitations from nonprofits, each measured the same way, with benchmarks by kind of email, focus area, budget, and region. Free to browse.

Related guides