The nonprofit donate page: what to fix first
November 9, 2026 · 4 min read
Someone reads your appeal on their phone, taps the button, and lands on an error page. Or on a page that asks for 14 fields. Or on a page that opens fine and then sends them to a payment screen with a different name on it. You will never hear from that person. A nonprofit donate page is the one page on your site where a failure costs a gift, and it is also the page the fewest people check.
You don't need a redesign. You need to go through it in a sensible order, because the first problem on the list usually hides the others.
Check that your nonprofit donate page can be found and loads
Start from outside your own building. Search for your organization's name and the word "donate" and see what comes up first. If a third-party listing outranks your own page, a donor may give through a profile you don't control, and you won't know.
Then click every donate link you have: the button on the home page, the link in the footer, the one in your email signature, and the one in your last appeal. Links break when a giving platform changes its address or a page is renamed. A dead link in a printed newsletter stays dead until the next print run, so check the web ones first.
Our website scan does the first part of this for you. It looks for a donate link on your site and checks whether it loads. It doesn't test your payment form, and it doesn't replace clicking through yourself.
Make the page work on a phone
Open the page on your own phone, on mobile data and not office wifi. Try to give $25 without help. Notice where you hesitate. The button may sit below a long block of text, or the amount buttons may be hard to tap, or the card field may zoom the screen in a way that hides the next one.
Say a small food pantry's board chair tries this and finds the donate button is the fourth thing down, under a photo and two paragraphs. Moving the button up and cutting one paragraph costs nothing and takes an afternoon. That is the kind of fix to look for, one that fits in a single sitting.
Cut the form to what you need
Every field you ask for is one more chance for someone to stop. Ask for the amount, a name, an email address, and the payment details. An address is needed for a mailed receipt, so ask for it only if you send one. Phone number and "how did you hear about us" can wait for the thank-you.
Keep the donor on a page that looks like yours. A page that jumps to an unfamiliar name at the last step reads as a mistake to the person on the other end. If your giving platform allows your logo and organization name at the top of the form, turn them on.
Say what the gift does and what comes back
A donor deciding between $25 and $50 wants one specific sentence, such as what $40 buys or who it reaches. Put it near the amount buttons, in the same place on every version of the page.
Behind the form, check what the donor receives. For a single gift of $250 or more, the IRS says a donor can deduct it only with a written acknowledgment from the charity. Many giving platforms send an automatic receipt. Make one test gift and read what arrives. If it doesn't say your organization's name and the amount, fix that before December. What a good thank-you says beyond the receipt is covered in the donation thank-you email.
Time the checks to the giving season
Candid's Krista Berry wrote in November 2022 that up to 31% of online year-end giving happens in December, and about 10% in the last three days of the year. Candid also advises updating your donation pages as part of year-end planning. Those are Candid's figures from its own sources, so treat them as a guide to timing and not a forecast for your list.
The practical point is that a donate page should be tested before the appeal goes out, not after the first complaint. If you write the appeal, the year-end appeal email pairs with this checklist.
Run through the page once a quarter with a short list: search, click each link, give a test gift on a phone, read the receipt. It takes under an hour. If you stop reading here and do only that, you will have caught most of what costs gifts. The scan is there if you want a second pair of eyes on the link and the rest of the site, and it's free to run.
Your donate page doesn't have to be beautiful. It has to load, make sense on a small screen, and tell a stranger what happens to their money.