← All guides

Executive director compensation and Form 990 line 15a

October 29, 2026 · 6 min read

Executive director compensation is the one decision a small board makes about a single person's money, and it's often made less carefully than anything else the board decides. The chair mentions a raise after a meeting, someone says that sounds fair, and the treasurer adjusts the budget. Months later the Form 990 asks whether the process included independent approval, comparison data, and a written record, and whoever is preparing the return checks yes because it feels mostly true.

It's worth doing properly, and for a small organization doing it properly takes about two hours a year.

What Form 990 line 15a actually asks

Part VI of Form 990 is a page of governance questions, and line 15a is the one about pay. It asks whether the process for setting the compensation of the organization's top management official, usually the executive director, included three things: review and approval by independent persons, comparability data, and contemporaneous substantiation of the deliberation and decision. Line 15b asks the same about other officers and key employees. If the answer is yes, the organization describes the process in Schedule O.

It's one question with three parts, and a yes means all three happened. A board that compared salaries but never wrote anything down should be answering no. The IRS instructions for Form 990 explain each part, and the rest of Part VI is covered in what the Form 990 governance questions are after.

The three parts aren't arbitrary. They mirror the IRS rules on excess benefit transactions, which say that when a board approves pay this way, the pay is presumed reasonable, and the IRS has to show otherwise rather than the organization having to prove it. That protection matters to the board. It matters just as much to the director, whose pay is printed on a public document every year.

Finding comparison pay data a small board can use

Comparability data means what similar people are paid for similar work at similar organizations. Similar means size, mission, and region, roughly in that order. A food bank with a $900,000 budget should not be comparing itself with a hospital foundation, or with a food bank 10 times its size.

There are three good sources, and none of them cost anything.

Other organizations' Form 990s. Part VII lists compensation for officers, directors, and key employees, including the executive director. Filings are searchable through Candid and other free lookup sites. Pick five to 10 organizations that look like yours and write down what they paid.

Your state association's salary survey. Many state associations of nonprofits publish a compensation survey every year or two, broken down by budget size and role. The National Council of Nonprofits keeps a directory of state associations.

The small-organization rule. For an organization with annual gross receipts under $1 million, the IRS regulations treat data from three comparable organizations in the same or similar communities as enough. That's a low bar, and there's no reason not to clear it.

Compare total compensation, not just salary. Health insurance, retirement contributions, and any housing or vehicle allowance all count, and leaving them out makes a package look smaller than it is.

An invented example: a youth arts organization with a $650,000 budget pulls the 990s of four similar organizations in its state. Their directors are paid between $68,000 and $84,000. Its own director is at $66,000 with no retirement contribution. That's a real finding, and it's written down before anyone has an opinion about it.

Who should vote on executive director compensation

Independent persons means board members with no conflict in this decision. In practice, that means nobody voting is related to the director, does business with them, is paid in a way the director controls, or would gain or lose anything depending on the outcome. Your conflict of interest policy should already say how to handle anyone who doesn't qualify: they say so, and they step out.

The director doesn't vote, and shouldn't be in the room for the discussion or the vote. They can and should make their case beforehand, in writing or in person, and then leave. That isn't a judgment about them. It's the condition that makes the decision defensible.

On a small board, the usual shape is that two or three people, often the chair and treasurer, gather the data and bring a recommendation, and the board votes on it. Some boards delegate the decision itself to a committee. Either works, as long as the bylaws allow it and everyone who votes is independent.

Writing it down at the time

Contemporaneous means at the time, not reconstructed later. The regulations ask for the record to be written before the later of the board's next meeting or 60 days after the decision, and then approved by the board within a reasonable time after that. In practice, that means minutes that get approved at the following meeting.

The minutes should say:

  • The terms that were approved, and the date.
  • Who was present, and who voted.
  • What comparability data the board looked at, and where it came from.
  • Anyone who had a conflict, and what they did about it.
  • If the approved pay is outside the range of the data, why.

Keep the data itself with the minutes. A spreadsheet of four organizations' 990 figures, saved alongside the record, is the whole file.

Keep pay separate from the review

Pay belongs in the same annual cycle as the executive director performance review, but not in the same conversation. Discuss performance, finish that, and take up pay a few weeks later with the data in hand. Mixed together, every comment about the year turns into an argument about a number.

The executive director review asks board members and the director separately whether the board compared pay with similar organizations, whether the people who approved it are free of family or business ties to the director, and whether the decision was written down. Where the organization files a full Form 990, the report sets its own line 15a answer beside those three. It's free, and there's no paid version of it.

None of this needs a consultant or a compensation study. It needs a spreadsheet, a short meeting with the director out of the room, and a paragraph in the minutes. Most boards can do it before the next 990 is due.

Executive director review

Review your executive director with the whole board

Board members answer in private, the director answers their own version, and staff can add their view if you have five or more. The committee gets a short report to read and then share with the director. It's free, and there is no paid version.

Related guides