Volunteer background checks: a policy for a small nonprofit
November 17, 2026 · 4 min read
A volunteer coordinator gets a call from a parent who wants to know whether the people who will be alone with the kids have been checked. She says yes, mostly, and then realizes she isn't sure what mostly means. Volunteer background checks are a decision a small nonprofit usually makes by habit. Writing the decision down, by role, takes an afternoon and saves the awkward call.
This is for a coordinator or board member who has been asked whether the organization screens volunteers and wants a plain answer. It isn't legal advice, and the law differs by state.
Decide who gets volunteer background checks and why
Not every volunteer needs the same screening. Sorting cans in a warehouse is a different risk from driving a client to an appointment or tutoring a child alone. The Nonprofit Risk Management Center recommends matching the rigor of screening to the risk of each position, which can mean several tracks within one organization.
A practical sort uses three questions about each role:
- Is the volunteer alone with children or vulnerable adults?
- Do they handle money, keys, or private records?
- Do they drive for the organization?
A yes to any of them puts the role in a higher track. Say a food pantry has 40 volunteers, of whom three deliver groceries to homebound seniors. Those three go in the higher track, and the rest get a lighter process. That's a defensible policy as long as it's written down and applied the same way each time.
Be careful about leaning on a check alone. The Center's 2008 national survey of volunteer screening found 12% of 517 human services organizations reported doing no screening, and its authors concluded that screening should be one part of a wider volunteer management approach that includes training and supervision. A clean record doesn't replace a two-person rule or someone checking in.
Check the law before you write the policy
State and local rules vary. BoardSource advises checking them first, because some places require checks for certain staff and volunteers, and others limit what an organization may ask or when, including "ban the box" rules. Funders and insurers may have their own expectations too. Ask your insurance agent and your state association of nonprofits, and see what your grant agreements say.
If the check involves a third-party screening company, get a lawyer's read on the consent and notice forms for your state. An hour of a lawyer's time is cheaper than a form that doesn't comply.
What the written policy should say
BoardSource's background check policy considerations list the elements any policy needs, and they translate directly to volunteers:
- Which crimes, if any, lead to automatic exclusion, and which don't.
- How often checks are repeated.
- A release form the volunteer signs.
- A chance for the person to respond to what the check finds.
BoardSource also stresses that a conviction, not an arrest, is the key factor, and that a check can't guarantee nothing will go wrong, only help reduce the risk. Decide who sees the results (as few people as possible), where the records are kept, and who makes the call on a close case. A second person, such as the executive director, is better than the coordinator deciding alone.
Put the policy in your volunteer handbook, and mention it in your sign-up form so no volunteer is surprised by a check after they've said yes.
Ask volunteers how it felt
A screening step is part of a volunteer's first experience, and it can feel welcoming or like suspicion depending on how it's explained. The volunteer experience survey asks volunteers, anonymously and in about four minutes each, about getting started and whether they feel valued. You won't see who said what. It's free, with no paid version.
Take the three roles in your organization that carry the most risk, and write one sentence for each describing how you screen them today. The gaps will show up on their own.