Staff feedback on the executive director, done carefully
October 29, 2026 · 6 min read
Staff see the parts of an executive director's job that a board never does. They know whether decisions get explained, whether a concern can be raised without consequences, and whether the director does what they said they would. A board reviewing its director without any of that is reviewing the half of the job it happens to see. But staff feedback on the executive director is also the most delicate thing a board can ask for, and done casually it can damage the director, the staff, and the board's own standing in one move.
The answer isn't to never ask. It's to ask under conditions that protect everyone, and to recognize the organizations where those conditions can't be met.
Why staff feedback on the executive director is different
Most surveys of staff ask about an organization: workload, communication, whether people expect to stay. That's why the usual advice on hearing from staff is to ask about the organization, not about a person. A review of the executive director breaks that rule on purpose. It asks about one named person, who supervises every person answering and will read the results.
That creates three risks a board has to take seriously.
People can be identified. On a team of six, the director knows everyone's views already. One harsh answer stands out, and the director will often guess, correctly or not, whose it was.
It can read as a route around the director. Staff learn there's an appeal above their boss. The director learns the board has doubts it hasn't voiced to their face. Neither is a good place to start the next year.
It can become a complaint box. An open invitation to comment on a person collects whatever has been building up, and the board ends up holding information it can't act on without managing staff, which isn't its job.
The conditions that make it safe enough
None of these are optional. If one can't be met, don't run the staff part.
Tell everyone the director will read the results. Before the first question, in plain words. Staff decide how honest to be based on what they're told, and pretending the director won't see it is the fastest way to lose their trust for good.
Tell the director first. The board decides whether to ask staff, but the director should never learn about it secondhand. Ideally they agree it's worth doing. A staff survey the director discovers by accident is a vote of no confidence whatever the results say.
Combine every answer. Staff results should only ever appear as averages across the group. Never as counts per answer, because "one of five strongly disagreed" names somebody in a team of five. Never as a list of who responded. There should be no way to find out who said what, including for the board.
Set a floor, and hold it. Don't show staff results at all unless at least five people answer, and at least 60% of the staff. Below that, withhold the whole staff section. A result from three people is a result that identifies three people. The broader reasoning is in how many responses a report needs.
No written comments in a small team. It's tempting to ask for comments, because they're the most vivid part of any review. But in a team of five or ten the director knows how everyone writes, and a verbatim comment can identify its author as surely as a name. No count of responses fixes that.
Ask about what staff actually see. Whether the director explains decisions that affect their work. Whether they can raise a concern without worrying how it will be received. Whether they're treated with respect, trusted to decide things in their own area, helped to grow, and given the tools to do the job. Don't ask staff about fundraising, the board relationship, or the budget. They mostly don't see it, and asking turns "don't know" into guesses.
Say what it isn't. It's not a grievance process. A complaint about specific conduct goes wherever the personnel policy says it goes, and the survey replaces none of that.
When not to ask staff at all
Some organizations should skip the staff part, and that's a sound decision, not a gap.
With fewer than five paid staff. There's no way to combine answers into something that protects anyone. The board can still ask the director how they think their staff would answer, and look at things like turnover. It can't ask the staff.
In the middle of something. A layoff, a reorganization, a complaint investigation, or an open conflict between the director and part of the staff. A survey run then measures the moment, not the year, and it can be read as the board taking sides.
When the board won't share the results with the director. If the board's plan is to read staff views privately and decide something about the director, that isn't a review. It's an investigation, and it needs a different process with legal advice.
What to do with what staff say
Read it next to the director's own view of the same things. The useful finding is rarely a single low average. It's the gap between how the director thinks they come across and how staff experience it, which is the same reason it helps to score the chief executive separately from the board. A director who rates their own communication highly while staff rate it low has something specific to work on, and it's usually something they can fix.
Then turn it into the director's goals for next year, in the same conversation as everything else in the executive director performance review. Don't try to work out who said what, and don't ask the director to. Look for patterns, not individual answers.
Guidance from BoardSource treats evaluating the chief executive as squarely the board's job. Staff input can inform that job. It can't do it for the board.
The executive director review includes an optional staff survey for organizations with five or more paid staff. Staff are told before the first question that the director will read the results, there are no written comments, and staff results appear only as averages once at least five people, and at least 60% of the staff, have answered. With fewer than five paid staff it isn't offered. It's free, and there's no paid version of it.
If you're unsure whether your organization is ready for this, it probably isn't yet. Run the review with the board and the director this year, and ask the question again next year.