Executive director employment contract: what to write down
November 14, 2026 · 4 min read
The director was hired eight years ago on a handshake and an offer letter that's been lost. Pay has changed four times, each time by a vote nobody wrote down clearly. Now the director is thinking about leaving, or the board is thinking about asking them to, and nobody can say what either side is owed. An executive director employment contract exists so that conversation has something to read.
This isn't legal advice. It's a list of what to settle, so that when you sit down with an employment lawyer in your state, you aren't starting from nothing.
What an executive director employment contract should cover
BoardSource publishes a checklist of elements to include in a chief executive employment contract. Read as a whole it has 19 items. Grouped by what the board has to decide, they come to five questions:
- How long, and how does it renew. BoardSource says a term of three years is most common in its experience, with renewal by mutual agreement.
- What is the job. A job description, which can be attached as an appendix, and who the director reports to.
- What does it pay. Starting salary, how it will be adjusted, any bonus or incentive and its range, retirement benefits, other benefits, and expense reimbursement.
- How will it be reviewed. The checklist asks the contract to say how often, by what method, and by whom.
- How does it end. Termination clauses, severance, and how disputes are resolved.
The rest are protective terms: confidentiality, a conflict-of-interest provision, limits on outside employment and board service, a noncompete, and which state's law governs. BoardSource cautions that a noncompete shouldn't be so restrictive that it deters applicants.
Settle how the review works before you need it
The review clause is the one boards skip, and it's the one that makes the rest workable. If the contract says the board will review the director annually against agreed goals, then a hard conversation in year four is part of the job, not a surprise.
Write down who runs it, when it happens, and what it's measured against. Our guides on the performance review and on setting goals cover how. If a bonus is tied to the review, say how the number is reached. A bonus that depends on "the board's impression" invites an argument.
Be plain about termination and severance
BoardSource describes the two cases this way: a with-cause termination releases the chief executive without severance, and a without-cause termination lets the organization release the executive but typically means severance is owed.
Say a board of seven offers a three-year contract with six months' severance if the director is let go without cause. Two years in, the board and director disagree about direction. Because the terms are written, the board knows what ending the arrangement costs, and the director knows what they would receive. Both can decide with open eyes.
Define "cause" in words a non-lawyer can follow. This is the part where a lawyer earns the fee, because the definition is where disputes happen.
Tie pay to the process, not just the number
Pay belongs in the contract and in the minutes. Our article on executive director pay and Form 990 covers how a small board sets it with comparison data and who votes. The contract should match what the board decided, and the minutes should show how it decided.
Have a board member who isn't conflicted, often the treasurer or chair, hold the signed copy, and put a second copy where the next chair can find it. The director's contract shouldn't live only in the director's files.
A short checklist for the next meeting
- Find the current agreement, or confirm there isn't one.
- Ask the director whether they want a written agreement.
- Pick two board members to draft with the director, and agree to hire an employment lawyer to read the draft.
- Put the review date in the contract.
The executive director review asks board members about the director's work in private, takes about eleven minutes each, and the director answers their own version. It's free, and there's no paid version. It gives the review something to start from. It doesn't write the contract, and it doesn't replace a lawyer.
A handshake works until the day it doesn't. Writing the terms down is a kindness to both sides.