← All guides

Executive director mid-year check-in: a short agenda

November 18, 2026 · 4 min read

The board agreed on goals for the executive director in January. In July, nobody has mentioned them since. By the time the review comes around, the director is surprised by what the board thinks, and the board is surprised by what has not happened. An executive director mid-year check-in is a half-hour conversation that prevents both surprises.

It is not a second review. There is no rating and no pay decision attached. It exists so that the goals stay alive between the start of the year and the end.

Why an executive director mid-year check-in helps

BoardSource says that every board should evaluate its chief executive each year, keep a written record of the results, and tie the review to the priorities identified earlier in the year. That works only if the priorities are still in people's heads when the review arrives. A check-in at the halfway point gives both sides a chance to say that a goal has changed, stalled, or been overtaken by events, while there is still time to do something about it.

It also helps the director. A funder pulls out, a key staff member leaves, a building floods. Goals set in January may no longer make sense. Better to revise them in July, in the open, than to be judged against them in December.

Who runs it

One person from the board, usually the chair or the chair of whatever committee handles the director's review, meets with the director. Keep the group small. Five board members around a table turns a check-in into a hearing.

If the board chair and the director are close friends, say so out loud and keep the conversation on the goals. The guide on the board chair and executive director relationship covers how to keep the friendship and the oversight from muddying each other.

A four-question agenda

Send the goals to the director a week before. Then cover these in order, taking notes as you go.

  1. Where does each goal stand? The director goes first, one goal at a time. Say a goal was to renew the two largest grants and one has been renewed. That is the report.
  2. What has changed? Is any goal now unrealistic, no longer important, or in need of a different measure?
  3. What does the director need from the board? An introduction, a decision, a clearer boundary, or time off. This is often the most useful question, and the one most often skipped.
  4. What should the board hear before the formal review? Anything either side would be uncomfortable raising for the first time in December.

If the answers to question two change a goal, write the new wording down and send it to the director. If you want help drafting goals worth checking in on, see setting goals for your executive director.

Write down what you agreed

Afterward, the board lead writes half a page: the date, the goals as they now stand, any changes, and anything the director asked for. Both people get a copy, and it goes in the file the board keeps for the annual review. Don't record opinions about the director's character. Record the goals and the plain facts about progress.

Where the check-in stops

A check-in is not the place to discuss pay, a contract, or whether the director should stay. Those belong in the annual review. Our guide on the executive director performance review covers that conversation, and the piece on how often to evaluate your executive director covers the calendar.

When you want the board's view in writing

If you'd like the board's views gathered before the annual review, the executive director review takes board members about eleven minutes each. Board members answer in private, the director answers their own version, and staff can add their view if you have five or more. The committee gets a short report to read and then share with the director. It's free, and there is no paid version.

Put the check-in on the calendar now, for a date six months from the day the goals were set. A meeting that is scheduled gets held.

Executive director review

Review your executive director with the whole board

Board members answer in private, the director answers their own version, and staff can add their view if you have five or more. The committee gets a short report to read and then share with the director. It's free, and there is no paid version.

Related guides