How often to evaluate your executive director
November 16, 2026 · 4 min read
The board hired the director three years ago. There was a review after the first six months, and a warm conversation at the end of the second year. Nothing since. Nobody decided to stop. The question of how often to evaluate your executive director just never got a date on the calendar.
A date matters more than a method. A review that has a place in the board's calendar happens, and one without usually doesn't.
How often to evaluate your executive director, per BoardSource
BoardSource recommends a yearly assessment of the chief executive. On the same page it warns that not assessing regularly "can lead to mistrust, strained working relationships, ongoing poor performance, and even turnover."
That is BoardSource's view, and a board with a good reason to do it differently can. But the case for once a year is practical. A year is long enough for goals to play out and short enough that the board remembers what they were. It also fits a fiscal year.
Pick a month and tie it to the goals
Choose the month and write it in the board calendar for next year. One option is the month after the fiscal year closes, when results are known. Others pick a quiet month, so the committee isn't reviewing in the middle of a campaign.
The review is only as good as the goals behind it. If the board and director haven't agreed on four to six goals, set them first. Reviewing against agreed goals is fairer than reviewing against impressions, and the director knows what they are being measured on.
Say a board's fiscal year ends in June. The director and the chair agree on goals in July, hold a short check-in in January, and run the full review in September. Each step has a month, and nobody is surprised.
Add one check-in between reviews
An annual review alone can feel like an ambush, because 11 months of silence ends in a verdict. A short mid-year conversation between the chair and the director fixes most of that. Use three questions: how are the goals going, what is getting in the way, and what does the board need to know or do?
Keep it to 30 to 45 minutes and take brief notes. It is not a second review. It's a chance to change a goal that no longer makes sense, and to say a concern out loud while it is small.
The chair and director need a working relationship for this to work. The relationship between the board chair and the director is worth reading if the standing meeting hasn't been happening.
Cover the exceptions
A new director needs a first review sooner, often around 90 days, to confirm goals and ask what is missing. After a hard year, a crisis, or a change in funding, a second look partway through can be reasonable.
Do not fold the review into the board's own evaluation. They are different exercises, with different confidentiality rules, as the difference between a board self-assessment and an executive evaluation explains. If your board hasn't done an executive review in more than a year, do one this cycle and don't wait for the perfect form.
Who does what
The chair or a small committee runs the process. The full board gives input. The director writes their own view. The committee puts the pieces together, meets with the director, and reports the outcome to the board. Compensation can follow the same calendar, and the performance review guide covers who leads it and how to document it.
If you'd like a structure, the executive director review asks board members in private, takes about eleven minutes per board member, and has the director answer their own version. Staff can add their view if you have five or more. It's free, and there's no paid version. It collects the views. The conversation with the director stays with the committee.
Put the date on the calendar before you close this page. A review that has a month attached to it usually gets held.