← All guides

Fundraising email call to action: keep it to one

November 22, 2026 · 4 min read

Open your last appeal and count the things it asks the reader to do. Give, share the post, forward it to a friend, follow you on social media, and come to the open house. Each ask felt reasonable when someone added it. Together they leave the reader with five choices and no clear next step. A fundraising email call to action is the one thing you want a person to do after reading, and the email is easier to write once you pick it.

What Candid advises about the call to action

Candid's advice on this is plain. In a post on writing a fundraising email, Jessica Chapman wrote in December 2020 that "you should remember to include only one CTA button in a fundraising email." Her reason is that "two or more options can make donors feel confused and fend them off."

She adds two details that matter in practice. You can place the same call to action in more than one spot, as long as it doesn't disrupt the structure or readability of the email. And the button can lead donors "straight to the landing page," so they finish in "no more than a few clicks." Both are her recommendations, not findings from a study, and the post is several years old. The advice is common sense more than data, which is a fair reason to test it on your own list.

Read the first part carefully. One button doesn't mean one sentence. A long appeal can say "give" at the top, in the middle, and at the end, and each of those can point to the same page.

Choosing the fundraising email call to action

Say a small food pantry is writing its December appeal. The email could ask for a gift, volunteer sign-ups for the holiday distribution, and canned goods at the front door. All three are true needs. Only one belongs on the button.

Pick by asking which action the rest of the email depends on. If the appeal is for the year-end fund, the button says "Give," and the volunteer and food drive requests move to a separate email, or a single line below the signature with no button. Readers who want to help another way will find it. Readers who were ready to give won't have to choose.

A few questions help settle it:

  • If only one thing happens, which one do you need? That is the call to action.
  • Does the ask fit the email's job? A thank-you email isn't the place for a new request. A welcome email has a different job than an appeal. The year-end appeal email covers one email with one job in more detail.
  • Can the reader do it from their phone in a minute? If not, fix the destination before you fix the wording.

Where the button leads

A clear button on the email doesn't help if the link opens a page that asks the reader to hunt for the gift form. Chapman's advice is to send them straight to the page where they give. That means the donate link goes to the form itself, not to your homepage and not to a general "ways to give" page with six options.

Click your own link from a phone, in a private browser window, as if you'd never visited. Count the taps from the email to a finished gift. If the page loads slowly, asks for fields you don't need, or buries the amount, the button's wording won't rescue it. Checking your donate page walks through that test in order.

Test the wording one change at a time

Testing the button's wording is a fair idea. If your list is large enough to split in half, change only the button text and keep everything else the same, so you know what made the difference. On a list of a few hundred people the result will be too noisy to trust, and you're better off picking a plain verb, writing it in the first person if that sounds like you, and moving on.

Check your last appeal in five minutes

  1. List every action the email asks for. Circle the one you needed most.
  2. Count the buttons. If there are two or more different ones, decide which stays.
  3. Click the remaining button on a phone. Time how long it takes to reach a finished gift.
  4. Reread the last paragraph. Does it end on the same ask as the first one?

If you want to see how other nonprofits structure their asks, the email gallery shows real appeals, each measured the same way, with benchmarks by kind of email, focus area, budget, and region. It's free to browse, and you can use it to compare how appeals of your type handle the button.

Your next appeal doesn't need a cleverer button. It needs one reader, one thing to do, and a page that is ready when they get there.

Email gallery

See what other nonprofits send their supporters

Real appeals, newsletters, and event invitations from nonprofits, each measured the same way, with benchmarks by kind of email, focus area, budget, and region. Free to browse.

Related guides