Nonprofit newsletter: what to put in it and how long
November 13, 2026 · 4 min read
The newsletter goes out whenever someone finds time, which turns out to be every seven weeks or so. It opens with a letter from the director, runs through four program updates, and ends with a donate button nobody has been told to expect. Everyone who works on it is tired of it by the end. A nonprofit newsletter doesn't have to work that way.
Give the nonprofit newsletter one job
Decide what a reader should know or do after finishing, and write toward that. Common jobs are keeping donors informed between appeals, bringing volunteers up to date, or telling people what the money did last quarter. Pick one. A newsletter that tries to inform, thank, recruit, and ask is four newsletters stapled together.
Say a small food pantry decides its newsletter has one job: show donors what their gifts bought. Every item gets measured against that. The volunteer shift notice goes in a separate message. The board retreat recap stays out. What's left is easy to write and easy to finish.
What to include
A workable shape for a short issue:
- One story, told through one person or moment. Keep it to a few paragraphs.
- A number with context. Meals served this quarter, and how that compares to the last one.
- A thank-you that names a group or a specific gift, with permission.
- One clear next step. Give, sign up, reply, or nothing at all.
Owen Jones, writing for Candid in 2021, advises keeping emails short, with short paragraphs, subheads, and bullets, because people usually scan rather than read. He also recommends subject lines of around 60 characters. These are practitioner tips, not rules, but they match what you can check yourself: open your last issue on a phone and see how far you get before you lose your place.
How long a nonprofit newsletter should be
No outside source we opened gives a word count that fits every organization. A better test is how long it takes. If a reader can finish it in about two minutes, it's probably the right size. If you have more to say, split it: a short issue that links to a longer story on your site keeps the email light and gives the story its own address.
Count what you cut. If each issue runs four items, try three. The item you remove is rarely missed.
Plan the year on one page
Consistency matters more than any single issue. Jones makes the same point in the Candid piece: plan content in advance and keep to a calendar. Lay out the year on one page, with the months your appeals fall in, the reports due, and the events you'll want covered. Then work out what each issue is for. A quarterly pace gives you four issues to plan, and a monthly one gives you twelve. Which fits depends on how much real news you have and how many hours you can give it. How often a nonprofit should send email walks through that tradeoff.
Keep the appeals separate. The newsletter builds the relationship that a year-end appeal later draws on, and a newsletter that always ends in an ask teaches readers to skim past it. If new subscribers hear nothing until the next issue, a welcome series fills the gap.
See what others send
It helps to look at other nonprofits' newsletters beside yours. The email gallery shows real emails from nonprofits, each measured the same way, and the benchmarks break results out by kind of email, focus area, budget, and region. It's free to browse, with no paid version. Use it to see how long and how often organizations like yours send, and judge your own against that, not against an average of everyone.
Pull up your last three issues and write the one-sentence job of each. If you can't, that's the edit to make first.