Executive director 360 review: should staff weigh in?
November 21, 2026 · 3 min read
The board chair wants to know what the staff think of the executive director, and a board member says it's called a 360 review and plenty of organizations do it. An executive director 360 review adds the views of the people who work with the director, not only the board. It can tell you things the board never sees, and it can go wrong in ways that are hard to repair.
What an executive director 360 review adds
The board sees the director at meetings and in monthly reports. It rarely sees how the director runs a staff meeting, handles a mistake, or treats a new hire. Staff see all of that. A review that includes staff covers ground the board can't.
It also adds risk. A staff member rating their own boss can feel exposed, and a director who hears criticism from people they supervise may react badly. Asking staff about their executive director covers those conditions in detail, including when not to ask.
What BoardSource says about who takes part
BoardSource's Assessment of the Chief Executive FAQ says it recommends including "any individual who can provide valuable insight into the work of the board or chief executive," and says these are typically board members. It adds that staff are welcome to participate if you feel their input would be valuable as you review the results. BoardSource's assessment page recommends doing the chief executive assessment annually and describes four areas: annual performance goals, core competencies, leadership qualities, and accomplishments and challenges.
So a 360 isn't required, and it isn't forbidden. It's a choice the governance committee makes on purpose, and BoardSource leaves it with you.
Decide five things before anyone is asked
Settle these in a short written plan, in this order.
- Who takes part. Board members, the director's own self-view, and which staff. "Direct reports" is a clearer group than "anyone who wants to."
- How many staff are needed. With three direct reports, any comment can be traced to a person by elimination. Say you have three: either widen the group or skip staff this year.
- What you'll ask. Questions about the director's work, such as clarity of direction and how they handle disagreement, not about personality.
- Who reads the raw answers. One person, such as the governance chair, with a promise not to forward individual comments.
- What the director sees. Themes and a summary, shared in a conversation, not a pile of quotes.
Write down what the results will not be used for. If staff think a bad comment could cost the director their job, they'll write safe answers, and you'll learn nothing.
Keep the board's view and the staff's view separate
Averaging board scores and staff scores into one number hides the useful part. A board that rates the director highly on communication while staff rate it low has found a gap worth talking about, and a blended average erases it. Show the two views side by side and let the director respond to the difference.
Why score the chief executive separately explains the reasoning in more depth. Give the director the chance to write a short response that sits beside the review, as when an executive director disagrees with the review describes.
A way to run it
The executive director review at this site asks board members to answer in private in about 11 minutes each, the director answers their own version, and staff can add their view if there are five or more. The committee gets a short report to read and then share with the director. It's free, and there's no paid version.
Either way, the plan on one page matters more than the tool. Decide who is asked, who reads what, and how the director hears it. Then tell the staff exactly that before you ask them anything.