← All guides

Who should see the executive director review

November 22, 2026 · 4 min read

The review is done, and a board member asks whether the whole board should read it. Another asks whether the director gets a copy. A third wonders what the staff who contributed will be told. Nobody planned for these questions, so the board answers them one at a time, in an awkward minute at the end of the meeting. Who should see the executive director review is easier to settle before anyone writes a word, and settling it takes about half an hour.

What BoardSource says about the full board

BoardSource's recommended board practices say that "the board evaluates the chief executive's performance annually, in writing and with the full board's involvement." They add that even if the chair or a committee leads the evaluation, "the full board participates." The same page says executive sessions "enhance relationships among board members and with the chief executive."

So the starting point is that the evaluation belongs to the whole board, not to the chair. A separate BoardSource page on what to evaluate says the process should be mutually agreed upon, should rely heavily on the job description, and should leave a written record of the results. Taken together, that points to a plan made in advance, with the director's knowledge, and kept on paper.

BoardSource doesn't say, on the pages I read, exactly who receives which document. That part is yours to decide, which is the reason to decide it deliberately.

Who should see the executive director review: four groups

Sort the people who might see the review into four groups and decide, for each, what they get.

  1. The full board. Do all directors read the complete results, or the committee's summary of them? BoardSource's language about the full board's involvement leans toward everyone seeing something. Many boards give directors the summary and keep individual comments with the committee.
  2. The committee or chair who leads. They usually see the most detail, including every comment. Decide in advance who holds the file.
  3. The executive director. Will they see the full results, a summary, or only the conversation? Whatever you pick, say it before the review starts, and read what happens when the director disagrees so you know what comes next.
  4. Staff and anyone else who contributed. If staff gave input, tell them in advance what happens to it. Asking staff about their executive director explains why that promise matters.

Say a board of eight has a three-person committee. Written up in advance, the plan might read: the committee reads every comment, the full board reads a two-page summary in executive session, and the director gets the same summary plus a meeting with the chair within a week. Staff are told that their comments go to the committee only, and that no summary quotes anyone.

Write it on one page

The page can be short:

  • Who reads the full results, by name or role.
  • Who reads the summary.
  • When the director sees it, and in what form.
  • Where the record is kept, and who can open it.
  • What contributors have been told.

Give the page to the director before the review starts. A review where the person being reviewed knows the rules is calmer than one where they find out afterward.

Keep the rule consistent from year to year. If this year's committee shares everything and next year's shares little, the director learns that the process depends on who's in charge, and the board learns it too.

What the executive director review shows

If you want a structured way to gather views, the executive director review asks board members the same questions about the director's past year, about eleven minutes each, and the director answers their own version. Board answers are private. The committee gets a short report showing where the board and the director see it differently, which it can read and then share with the director. Staff can add their view if you have five or more paid staff. It's free, and there's no paid version. The report is an input. Who reads it, and what follows, is the board's decision.

The review will be easier on everyone if the access plan exists before the first comment is written. One page, agreed once, is enough.

Executive director review

Review your executive director with the whole board

Board members answer in private, the director answers their own version, and staff can add their view if you have five or more. The committee gets a short report to read and then share with the director. It's free, and there is no paid version.

Related guides